vti_encoding:SR|utf8-nl vti_timelastmodified:TR|09 Dec 2014 21:25:25 -0000 vti_extenderversion:SR|5.0.2.6790 vti_shadowfiles:VX| vti_cacheddtm:TX|09 Dec 2014 21:25:25 -0000 vti_filesize:IR|58637 vti_cachedtitle:SR|Kopel's Corner weblog, March-April 2012 vti_cachedbodystyle:SR| vti_cachedlinkinfo:VX|G|corner.dwt Q|styles.css Q|mobile.css X|mobile2.css Q|../TOC.css H|../index.htm S|../images/iilogo.jpg H|http://volokh.com/2012/04/18/post-argument-debate-on-the-constitutionality-of-obamacare/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|ftp://nsweb.law.du.edu/spring2012videos/specialevents-meetings/Affordable\\ Care\\ Act\\ Debate,\\ Room\\ 190,\\ 4-11-12.wmv H|http://volokh.com/category/commerce-clause/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-history/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ H|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ H|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ H|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ H|http://volokh.com/category/necessary-and-proper/ H|http://volokh.com/category/taxing-and-spending-clause/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/04/05/canada-abolishes-long-gun-registry/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx H|http://www.cdnshootingsports.org/2012/02/meet-the-man-responsible-for-the-death-of-canadas-gun-registry.html H|http://www.cdnshootingsports.org/index.html H|http://www.nfa.ca/index.php H|http://www.nfa.ca/resource-items/david-tomlinson-rip-september-18-2007 H|http://volokh.com/category/canada/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/registration/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/04/02/president-obama-versus-the-constitution/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/GPO-CONAN-2010/content-detail.html H|http://www.nrlc.org/news/2007/NRL08/PresidentColumnPage3.html H|http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2008/06/kaffee-vs-jessu/ H|http://www.davekopel.com/CJ/LawRev/Taking_Federalism_Seriously.htm H|http://volokh.com/category/congress/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-history/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-theory/ H|http://volokh.com/category/counter-terrorism-policy/ H|http://volokh.com/category/executivebranch/ H|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ H|http://volokh.com/category/growth-of-government/ H|http://volokh.com/category/habeas/ H|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ H|http://volokh.com/category/history/ H|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ H|http://volokh.com/category/jefferson/ H|http://volokh.com/category/judicial-power/ H|http://volokh.com/category/obama/ H|http://volokh.com/category/presidency/ H|http://volokh.com/category/public-opinion/ H|http://volokh.com/category/supreme-court/ H|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ H|http://volokh.com/category/war-on-terror/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/04/01/andy-koppelman-wonders-are-people-who-disagree-with-him-just-stupid-or-are-are-they-insane/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://volokh.com/2010/03/22/is-the-tax-power-infinite/ H|http://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2010/01/23/on-the-constitution-beware-the-word-clearly/ H|http://lsolum.typepad.com/legaltheory/2012/04/koppelman-on-frivolous-opinions.html H|http://yalelawjournal.org/the-yale-law-journal-pocket-part/supreme-court/bad-news-for-professor-koppelman:-the-incidental-unconstitutionality-of-the-individual-mandate/ H|http://yalelawjournal.org/the-yale-law-journal-pocket-part/constitutional-law/bad-news-for-john-marshall/ H|http://legalworkshop.org/2012/02/06/the-incidental-unconstitutionality-of-the-individual-mandate H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-theory/ H|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ H|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ H|http://volokh.com/category/psychology/ H|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/03/29/nearing-the-end-of-the-search-for-the-non-existent-limiting-principles/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://balkin.blogspot.com/2012/03/five-limiting-principles.html H|http://volokh.com/category/commerce-clause/ H|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ H|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ H|http://volokh.com/category/fifth-amendment/ H|http://volokh.com/category/growth-of-government/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ H|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ H|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ H|http://volokh.com/category/necessary-and-proper/ H|http://volokh.com/category/new-class/ H|http://volokh.com/category/regulation/ H|http://volokh.com/category/supreme-court/ H|http://volokh.com/category/taxes/ H|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/03/27/floridas-self-defense-laws/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ K|http://volokh.com/2012/03/27/floridas-self-defense-laws/ H|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/crime-victims-rights/ H|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/ H|http://volokh.com/category/criminal-procedure/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ H|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/self-defense/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/03/08/publication-party-for-firearms-law-and-the-second-amendment/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://calendars.fordham.edu/EventList.aspx H|http://www.aspenlaw.com/product.asp H|http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1454805110/thevolocons0d-20/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ K|http://volokh.com/2012/03/08/publication-party-for-firearms-law-and-the-second-amendment/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-colorado-students-for-concealed-carry-on-campus-v-regents/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://www.davekopel.org/Briefs/County-Sheriffs-of-Colo.pdf H|http://www.courts.state.co.us/Courts/Supreme_Court/opinions/2010/10SC344.pdf H|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ K|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-colorado-students-for-concealed-carry-on-campus-v-regents/ H|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-maryland-woollard-v-sheridan/ H|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ H|http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benson_Everett_Legg H|http://www.saf.org/viewpr-new.asp H|http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/breaking/bs-md-handgun-law-20120305,0,6504189.story H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ H|http://volokh.com/category/guns/right-to-carry/ H|http://www.volokh.com/author/davek/ H|2012-Nov-Dec.html H|2012-Sept-Oct.html H|2012-Jul-Aug.htm H|2012-May-Jun.htm H|2012-Mar-Apr.htm H|2012-Jan-Feb.htm H|2011-Nov-Dec.htm H|2011-Sept-Oct.htm H|2011-July-August.htm H|2011-May-June.htm H|2011-Mar-Apr.htm H|2011-Jan-Feb.htm H|2010-November-December.htm H|2010-September-October.htm H|2010-July-August.htm H|2010-April-June.htm H|2010-January-March.htm H|2009-Oct-December.htm H|2009-July-September.htm H|2009-April-June.htm H|2009-January-March.htm H|2008-October-December.htm H|2008-July-September.htm H|2008-April-June.htm H|2008-January-to-March.htm H|Corner-Archive-2007-Part-two.htm H|Corner-Archive-2007-Part-one.htm H|Corner-Archive-2006-part2.htm H|Corner-Archive-2006.htm H|Corner-Archive-2005.htm H|Corner-Archive-2004.htm H|Corner-Archive-2003.htm H|Corner-Archive.htm H|http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php S|http://s7.addthis.com/js/250/addthis_widget.js H|http://www.davekopel.org/feed.xml S|../images/RSSbutton.gif H|http://twitter.com/davekopel vti_cachedsvcrellinks:VX|FGUS|Corner/corner.dwt NQUS|Corner/styles.css NQUS|Corner/mobile.css NXUS|Corner/mobile2.css FQUS|TOC.css FHUS|index.htm FSUS|images/iilogo.jpg NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/04/18/post-argument-debate-on-the-constitutionality-of-obamacare/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHUS|ftp://nsweb.law.du.edu/spring2012videos/specialevents-meetings/Affordable\\ Care\\ Act\\ Debate,\\ Room\\ 190,\\ 4-11-12.wmv NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/commerce-clause/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-history/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/necessary-and-proper/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/taxing-and-spending-clause/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/04/05/canada-abolishes-long-gun-registry/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://www.parl.gc.ca/HousePublications/Publication.aspx NHHS|http://www.cdnshootingsports.org/2012/02/meet-the-man-responsible-for-the-death-of-canadas-gun-registry.html NHHS|http://www.cdnshootingsports.org/index.html NHHS|http://www.nfa.ca/index.php NHHS|http://www.nfa.ca/resource-items/david-tomlinson-rip-september-18-2007 NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/canada/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/registration/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/04/02/president-obama-versus-the-constitution/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/GPO-CONAN-2010/content-detail.html NHHS|http://www.nrlc.org/news/2007/NRL08/PresidentColumnPage3.html NHHS|http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2008/06/kaffee-vs-jessu/ NHHS|http://www.davekopel.com/CJ/LawRev/Taking_Federalism_Seriously.htm NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/congress/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-history/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-theory/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/counter-terrorism-policy/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/executivebranch/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/growth-of-government/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/habeas/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/history/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/jefferson/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/judicial-power/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/obama/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/presidency/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/public-opinion/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/supreme-court/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/war-on-terror/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/04/01/andy-koppelman-wonders-are-people-who-disagree-with-him-just-stupid-or-are-are-they-insane/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2010/03/22/is-the-tax-power-infinite/ NHHS|http://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2010/01/23/on-the-constitution-beware-the-word-clearly/ NHHS|http://lsolum.typepad.com/legaltheory/2012/04/koppelman-on-frivolous-opinions.html NHHS|http://yalelawjournal.org/the-yale-law-journal-pocket-part/supreme-court/bad-news-for-professor-koppelman:-the-incidental-unconstitutionality-of-the-individual-mandate/ NHHS|http://yalelawjournal.org/the-yale-law-journal-pocket-part/constitutional-law/bad-news-for-john-marshall/ NHHS|http://legalworkshop.org/2012/02/06/the-incidental-unconstitutionality-of-the-individual-mandate NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-theory/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/psychology/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/29/nearing-the-end-of-the-search-for-the-non-existent-limiting-principles/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://balkin.blogspot.com/2012/03/five-limiting-principles.html NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/commerce-clause/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/constitutional-law/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/federalism/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/fifth-amendment/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/growth-of-government/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/health-care/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/individual-mandate/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/necessary-and-proper/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/new-class/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/regulation/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/supreme-court/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/taxes/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/27/floridas-self-defense-laws/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/27/floridas-self-defense-laws/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/crime-victims-rights/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/criminal-procedure/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/criminallaw/self-defense/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/08/publication-party-for-firearms-law-and-the-second-amendment/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://calendars.fordham.edu/EventList.aspx NHHS|http://www.aspenlaw.com/product.asp NHHS|http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1454805110/thevolocons0d-20/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/08/publication-party-for-firearms-law-and-the-second-amendment/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-colorado-students-for-concealed-carry-on-campus-v-regents/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://www.davekopel.org/Briefs/County-Sheriffs-of-Colo.pdf NHHS|http://www.courts.state.co.us/Courts/Supreme_Court/opinions/2010/10SC344.pdf NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/uncategorized/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-colorado-students-for-concealed-carry-on-campus-v-regents/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/2012/03/05/right-to-carry-victory-in-maryland-woollard-v-sheridan/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/author/davek/ NHHS|http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benson_Everett_Legg NHHS|http://www.saf.org/viewpr-new.asp NHHS|http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/breaking/bs-md-handgun-law-20120305,0,6504189.story NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/ NHHS|http://volokh.com/category/guns/right-to-carry/ NHHS|http://www.volokh.com/author/davek/ FHUS|Corner/2012-Nov-Dec.html FHUS|Corner/2012-Sept-Oct.html FHUS|Corner/2012-Jul-Aug.htm FHUS|Corner/2012-May-Jun.htm FHUS|Corner/2012-Mar-Apr.htm FHUS|Corner/2012-Jan-Feb.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-Nov-Dec.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-Sept-Oct.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-July-August.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-May-June.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-Mar-Apr.htm FHUS|Corner/2011-Jan-Feb.htm FHUS|Corner/2010-November-December.htm FHUS|Corner/2010-September-October.htm FHUS|Corner/2010-July-August.htm FHUS|Corner/2010-April-June.htm FHUS|Corner/2010-January-March.htm FHUS|Corner/2009-Oct-December.htm FHUS|Corner/2009-July-September.htm FHUS|Corner/2009-April-June.htm FHUS|Corner/2009-January-March.htm FHUS|Corner/2008-October-December.htm FHUS|Corner/2008-July-September.htm FHUS|Corner/2008-April-June.htm FHUS|Corner/2008-January-to-March.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2007-Part-two.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2007-Part-one.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2006-part2.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2006.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2005.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2004.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive-2003.htm FHUS|Corner/Corner-Archive.htm NHHS|http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php NSHS|http://s7.addthis.com/js/250/addthis_widget.js NHHS|http://www.davekopel.org/feed.xml FSUS|images/RSSbutton.gif NHHS|http://twitter.com/davekopel vti_cachedneedsrewrite:BR|true vti_cachedhasbots:BR|true vti_cachedhastheme:BR|false vti_cachedhasborder:BR|false vti_botnavbits:SW| vti_botlinkbars:VW|S|sid:1001 vti_botnavbarthemes:VR| vti_botnavbarfeatures:VR|s vti_error0:SX|Page "Corner/2012-Mar-Apr.htm" contains an unknown FrontPage component: "Script". vti_error:IX|1 vti_metatags:VR|viewport width=device-width,\\ initial-scale=1.0,\\ maximum-scale=2.0,\\ user-scalable=yes HTTP-EQUIV=Content-Language en-us HTTP-EQUIV=Content-Type text/html;\\ charset=windows-1252 vti_charset:SR|windows-1252 vti_language:SR|en-us vti_title:SR|Kopel's Corner weblog, March-April 2012 vti_lineageid:SR|{30898DB1-36B6-47FC-8D66-AAB5EC908090} vti_backlinkinfo:VX|awstats/1407/awstats.1478971.1407.urldetail.html awstats/1408/awstats.1478971.1408.urlentry.html Corner/corner.dwt awstats/1212/awstats.1478971.1212.urldetail.html awstats/1301/awstats.1478971.1301.urldetail.html awstats/1404/awstats.1478971.1404.urlexit.html Corner/2010-July-August.htm Corner/2011-Sept-Oct.htm awstats/1308/awstats.1478971.1308.urldetail.html Corner/2008-January-to-March.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2005.htm awstats/1206/awstats.1478971.1206.urlexit.html awstats/1310/awstats.1478971.1310.urldetail.html awstats/1407/awstats.1478971.1407.urlentry.html awstats/1209/awstats.1478971.1209.urldetail.html awstats/1209/awstats.1478971.1209.urlentry.html awstats/1406/awstats.1478971.1406.urldetail.html awstats/1211/awstats.1478971.1211.urldetail.html awstats/1205/awstats.1478971.1205.urldetail.html awstats/1301/awstats.1478971.1301.urlentry.html awstats/1307/awstats.1478971.1307.urlentry.html awstats/1402/awstats.1478971.1402.urldetail.html awstats/1406/awstats.1478971.1406.urlentry.html awstats/1407/awstats.1478971.1407.urlexit.html awstats/1412/awstats.1478971.1412.urlexit.html Corner/Corner-Archive-2006-part2.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2007-Part-two.htm awstats/1210/awstats.1478971.1210.urlentry.html awstats/1307/awstats.1478971.1307.urldetail.html awstats/1409/awstats.1478971.1409.urldetail.html awstats/1411/awstats.1478971.1411.urldetail.html Corner/2012-Nov-Dec.html Corner/CornerPDA.htm awstats/1303/awstats.1478971.1303.urldetail.html awstats/1405/awstats.1478971.1405.urlentry.html Corner/2009-April-June.htm Corner/2009-Oct-December.htm awstats/1207/awstats.1478971.1207.urlentry.html awstats/1208/awstats.1478971.1208.urldetail.html awstats/1210/awstats.1478971.1210.urldetail.html awstats/1303/awstats.1478971.1303.urlexit.html awstats/1306/awstats.1478971.1306.urlentry.html awstats/1402/awstats.1478971.1402.urlexit.html awstats/1405/awstats.1478971.1405.urldetail.html Corner/2009-January-March.htm Corner/2012-Sept-Oct.html Corner/Corner-Archive.htm awstats/1312/awstats.1478971.1312.urldetail.html awstats/1406/awstats.1478971.1406.urlexit.html awstats/1411/awstats.1478971.1411.urlexit.html Corner/2010-November-December.htm Corner/2011-Mar-Apr.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2004.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2006.htm awstats/1305/awstats.1478971.1305.urlentry.html awstats/1306/awstats.1478971.1306.urldetail.html awstats/1401/awstats.1478971.1401.urldetail.html awstats/1404/awstats.1478971.1404.urlentry.html awstats/1408/awstats.1478971.1408.urldetail.html awstats/1412/awstats.1478971.1412.urlentry.html Corner/2010-April-June.htm Corner/2011-May-June.htm awstats/1401/awstats.1478971.1401.urlexit.html awstats/1410/awstats.1478971.1410.urldetail.html Corner/2008-July-September.htm Corner/2009-July-September.htm Corner/2010-January-March.htm Corner/2012-Jan-Feb.htm Corner/Latest.htm awstats/1207/awstats.1478971.1207.urldetail.html awstats/1302/awstats.1478971.1302.urldetail.html awstats/1403/awstats.1478971.1403.urlentry.html awstats/1404/awstats.1478971.1404.urldetail.html awstats/1410/awstats.1478971.1410.urlexit.html Corner/2011-Nov-Dec.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2007-Part-one.htm awstats/1304/awstats.1478971.1304.urlentry.html awstats/1306/awstats.1478971.1306.urlexit.html awstats/1309/awstats.1478971.1309.urldetail.html awstats/1311/awstats.1478971.1311.urldetail.html awstats/1405/awstats.1478971.1405.urlexit.html awstats/1409/awstats.1478971.1409.urlentry.html awstats/1411/awstats.1478971.1411.urlentry.html Corner/2011-July-August.htm awstats/1205/awstats.1478971.1205.urlentry.html awstats/1212/awstats.1478971.1212.urlexit.html Corner/2008-October-December.htm awstats/1305/awstats.1478971.1305.urldetail.html awstats/1402/awstats.1478971.1402.urlentry.html Corner/2008-April-June.htm awstats/1410/awstats.1478971.1410.urlentry.html awstats/1206/awstats.1478971.1206.urldetail.html awstats/1212/awstats.1478971.1212.urlentry.html awstats/1305/awstats.1478971.1305.urlexit.html awstats/1401/awstats.1478971.1401.urlentry.html awstats/1403/awstats.1478971.1403.urldetail.html Corner/2011-Jan-Feb.htm awstats/1412/awstats.1478971.1412.urldetail.html Corner/2010-September-October.htm Corner/2012-Mar-Apr.htm Corner/Corner-Archive-2003.htm awstats/1304/awstats.1478971.1304.urldetail.html Corner/2012-May-Jun.htm PDA.htm awstats/1403/awstats.1478971.1403.urlexit.html Corner/2012-Jul-Aug.htm